Logo

Premium Payment Options
 
Grange Mutual:
  • Credit Card & Check by Phone Payments can be called directly to 800-425-1100 or you can make payments online at: www.grangeinsurance.com.  There are no additional fees to pay online or by phone.
  • Pay by Mail
    Grange Insurance Companies 
    PO Box 740604 
    Cincinnati OH 45274-0604
 
Westfield Group:
  • Credit Card & Check by Phone payments can be called directly to 800-766-9133, or you can make payments online at : www.westfieldinsurance.com.  A $5.95 fee is assessed for each transaction.
  • Pay by Mail: 
    Westfield Group 
    PO Box 9001566 
    Lexington KY 40290-1566
 
Western Reserve Group:
  • Credit Card & Check by Phone payments can be called directly to 1/877/566/0699 or you can make payments online at : www.wrg-ins.com. A $1.99 fee is assessed for personal and commercial lines.
  • Pay by Mail: 
    Western Reserve Group
    PO Box 36
    Wooster OH 44691
 
Progressive:
  • Credit Card & Check by Phone payments can be called directly to 1-800-876-5581 or pay online at www.progressiveagent.com.  There are no known fees for each transaction.
  • Pay by Mail: 
    Progressive Insurance 
    PO Box 182009 
    Columbus OH 43218-2009
 
Brotherhood Mutual:
  • Pay online at: www.brotherhoodmutual.com. The online premium payment service can only accept an ACH transfer from a checking or savings account. There are no additional fees to pay online.
  • Pay by Mail: 
    Lockbox A 
    Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company 
    PO Box 2589 
    Fort Wayne IN 46801-2589