Make a Payment

Need to make a payment on your policy? We can help with payment options.

To make a payment on your insurance policy, please contact Brotherhood Mutual or send a check directly to the company using the address listed below.  For your convenience, Brotherhood Mutual accepts online payments.

If you have questions about making a payment, you can also contact us at 800-686-1133.

Brotherhood Mutual

Lockbox A
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company
P.O. Box 2589
Fort Wayne, IN  46801-2589


Online Payments

Make a Payment